Risk Partners Life Sciences Roundtable 2025, thank you very much!
Risk Partners Life Sciences Roundtable 2025, thank you very much!
Auf einen Blick:
Eine Title Insurance schützt vor finanziellen Folgen, wenn die rechtliche Inhaberschaft, Übertragbarkeit oder Lastenfreiheit eines Vermögensgegenstands anders ausfällt als angenommen. Versichert werden können insbesondere Grundstücke, grundstücksgleiche Rechte und Gesellschaftsanteile, etwa bei Lücken in der Erwerbs- oder Beteiligungskette, besseren Rechten Dritter, Belastungen, Zustimmungsmängeln oder fehlender Berechtigung des Veräußerers.
Die Title Insurance setzt bei der rechtlichen Zuordnung eines Vermögensgegenstands an: Wer ist materiell berechtigt, war die Übertragung wirksam und können Rechte Dritter Eigentum, Anteilsinhaberschaft, Verwertbarkeit oder Wert des erworbenen Rechts beeinträchtigen? Der Begriff „Title“ meint dabei nicht den deutschen Vollstreckungstitel, sondern die rechtliche Inhaberschaft oder Berechtigung, insbesondere an Grundstücken, grundstücksgleichen Rechten und Gesellschaftsanteilen.
Je nach Risikolage kommt eine eigenständige Police für definierte Title-Risiken oder eine Top-up-Deckung oberhalb einer W&I-Police für Title- und Capacity-Garantien in Betracht. Die eigenständige Police knüpft an das versicherte Ereignis und den daraus entstehenden Schaden an. Die Top-up-Lösung bleibt dagegen mit der W&I- und Garantie-Mechanik des Kaufvertrags verbunden.
Separate policy for unknown title risks and specifically included individual risks:
A standalone title insurance policy is independent of W&I insurance and can also be used outside of an ongoing sale process, such as in refinancing, exit preparations, portfolio transactions, loan book sales, or acquisition situations without reliable seller warranties. The policy covers defined events relating to legal ownership, transfer, or freedom from encumbrances, such as the seller’s lack of authority, superior rights of third parties, existing encumbrances, defective prior transfer documents, missing consents, forgery, fraud, undue influence, lack of legal capacity, or comparable defects in the chain of title.
Die Versicherungssumme kann sich am Kaufpreis, am Marktwert des betroffenen Vermögensgegenstands oder am Finanzierungsrisiko orientieren. Die Laufzeit ist typischerweise nicht an die Garantiefrist des Kaufvertrags gebunden, sondern an die Eigentümerdauer des Versicherten gekoppelt.
Top-up coverage in addition to a W&I policy:
Die Top-up-Deckung erhöht die Absicherung für Title- und Capacity-Garantien oberhalb der regulären W&I-Limits. Sie konzentriert sich auf grundlegende Garantien zu Eigentum, Berechtigung und Verfügungsbefugnis, bei denen ein Schaden wirtschaftlich bis zum Verlust der Beteiligung oder des betroffenen Vermögensgegenstands reichen kann. Zahlungen oder erstattungsfähige Beträge aus der zugrunde liegenden W&I-Police werden auf den vereinbarten Selbstbehalt bzw. Anknüpfungspunkt der Top-up-Deckung angerechnet, mindern deren Versicherungssumme jedoch nicht. Die Versicherungssumme der Top-up-Deckung reduziert sich erst durch eigene Zahlungen aus dieser Police, nach Maßgabe der Policenbedingungen.
From a financial perspective, the top-up solution is particularly worthwhile when the goal is to specifically increase only the coverage for ownership, title, and power of disposal, without raising the entire W&I limit. This is typically due to the capital structure of private equity acquisition vehicles: These are deliberately kept undercapitalized to isolate the financial risk of the transaction. A buyer therefore cannot rely on the acquisition vehicle itself to be solvent in the event of a claim. While escrow deposits or guarantees from the fund company resolve this problem, they tie up capital for years and are correspondingly capital-intensive. Top-up coverage provides the same financial protection without tying up capital; typically, it comes at a premium that is significantly lower than the cost of a correspondingly expanded W&I policy.
W&I-Versicherung: Garantien zur rechtlichen Inhaberschaft, Berechtigung und Verfügungsbefugnis gehören üblicherweise zu den grundlegenden Garantien einer W&I-Police. Der Schutz ist dort jedoch durch das vereinbarte W&I-Limit begrenzt, häufig im Bereich von 10 bis 30 % des Enterprise Value, in Einzelfällen auch darüber. Ein schwerer Title-Mangel kann wirtschaftlich deutlich darüber hinausgehen und im Extremfall den Erwerb der Beteiligung oder des Vermögensgegenstands selbst betreffen. Title Insurance kann diese Lücke entweder als Top-up oberhalb der W&I-Police oder als eigenständige Police adressieren.
Title-to-Property and Title-to-Shares: When acquiring real estate-related shares, a distinction must also be made between coverage for the property itself and coverage for the shareholding in the holding company. Title-to-Property protects the legal title to the property or rights equivalent to real property. Title-to-Shares protects the legal title to the shares of the property company. Some providers require that Title-to-Shares be combined with Title-to-Property coverage for the underlying asset; others can insure the shareholding independently of real estate coverage. This distinction is crucial when selecting a provider, especially for share deals involving German property companies.
German Land Registry Law: For real estate in Germany, the public faith in the land registry under Sections 891 and 892 of the German Civil Code (BGB) provides comparatively strong legal protection. A traditional title insurance policy is therefore not always the obvious choice for purely German real estate transactions involving properties with a clear land registry status. However, title insurance may still be relevant if the land register does not fully reflect the relevant risk areas—for example, in cases of disclosed or suspected encumbrances not recorded in the land register, missing or disputed rights of access, utility lines, or use; complex portfolio and financing situations; cross-border real estate holdings; or acquisitions through a special-purpose vehicle.
In practice, the level of protection afforded by the acquisition of GmbH shares in good faith under § 16(3) GmbHG is often overestimated. The list of shareholders does not confer comprehensive public faith. While it may, under certain conditions, protect good faith in the entitlement of the shareholder listed therein, it does not cover every source of error relevant to title. Encumbrances on the share, restrictions on disposal, non-compliance with internal or external approval requirements, prior assignments subject to a condition precedent, erroneous prior divisions or mergers of shares, and other defects in the historical chain of ownership must be examined separately.
With stocks, the risk situation is different, but not necessarily simpler. While registered shares are recorded in a share register that serves as proof of ownership in relation to the company, this register does not replace a land registry-like register for the acquisition of rights in rem. Different issues regarding proof of ownership and transferability may arise in the case of bearer shares, registered shares, restricted registered shares, and securitized or unsecuritized shares. Therefore, an independent review of share entitlement and the chain of transfer remains particularly relevant in the case of older, multi-tiered, or internationally structured chains of ownership.
In the case of ownership chains involving foreign entities, title-related issues may also arise from the applicable articles of incorporation, legal capacity, authority to represent the company, evidence of registration, approval requirements under the articles of association, or the validity of prior transfer steps. This applies in particular to cases involving third countries, older ownership structures, incomplete documentation, or chains of ownership in which multiple legal systems intersect. For EU/EEA companies, however, a blanket reliance on the former “seat theory” is too undifferentiated; here, recognition of the corporate form is much more firmly established by case law on the freedom of establishment.
In transactions involving a multi-tiered or historically unclear chain of ownership—such as those resulting from reorganizations, accretions, successions, trust arrangements, foreign connections at the shareholder level, or older share transfers—a residual risk may therefore remain that cannot be completely ruled out either by the information in the registry or through legal due diligence. Title insurance can cover the remaining economic risk, provided that it was either unknown or, as a known individual risk, was expressly disclosed, reviewed by the insurer, and included in the scope of coverage.
Praktisch relevant wird Title Insurance vor allem dort, wo ein Eigentums-, Anteils- oder Übertragungsrisiko den Vollzug, die Finanzierung oder die geplante Veräußerung gefährdet. Der typische Auslöser liegt dabei selten beim Käufer allein: Verkäufer und Fonds nutzen die Police, um Title-bezogene Rückbehalte und langfristige Haftungspositionen zu vermeiden; Finanzierer verlangen sie, wenn Eigentums- oder Rangfragen die Werthaltigkeit der Besicherung berühren. Für Rechtsberater wird sie zum Instrument, wenn ein identifiziertes Risiko sich im verfügbaren Zeitraum weder vollständig aufklären noch rechtssicher beseitigen lässt. Die folgenden Konstellationen zeigen, wie das in der Praxis aussieht.
Increase in Title coverage up to the purchase price or market value, while the remaining guarantee coverage remains within the regular W&I limits.
Refinancing an existing property, preparing for a fund exit, or simply a long-time owner’s desire for clarity regarding a historically unclear chain of ownership, without a sale being imminent.
Multiple transfers, restructurings, successions, trust arrangements, or foreign connections at the shareholder level, where tracing the chain back to the company’s incorporation is not economically feasible or legally possible to the fullest extent.
Target companies or real estate portfolios in jurisdictions with differing registration systems, incomplete historical documentation, past privatization, expropriation, or restitution issues, or pending proceedings regarding ownership and use. Particularly in the case of cross-border portfolios with historically accumulated issues related to registration, privatization, or restitution, a title or specific risk policy may be relevant if financiers or acquirers require financial protection before a proceeding is finally concluded.
This is particularly true for sales by funds in liquidation, where a retention is intended to cover exclusively or primarily title-related risks or specifically assessed individual risks. The policy does not replace general seller liability, but it can provide targeted financial protection for clearly defined risks related to ownership, shares, or transfer.
The acquisition of multiple assets using debt financing, in which the timely cancellation or priority-compliant discharge of existing encumbrances is not fully guaranteed by the closing date, and the new lender insists on first-priority collateral. The policy does not replace the actual removal of encumbrances, but it can protect the purchaser and the lender financially against losses arising from the failure to achieve the expected unencumbered or properly ranked status in a timely or effective manner.
Acquisition of shares or assets in situations where the historical chain of title has gaps, the seller provides only limited warranties, or prior transfers may be relevant under insolvency law. The precise scope of coverage as defined in the policy terms is decisive: title insurance policies may cover certain defects in the historical chain of title. Claims arising from insolvency, creditor, or avoidance rights, on the other hand, are often excluded or insurable only under strict conditions. Such risks must therefore be assessed early on as potential individual risks and expressly addressed in the policy.
Acquisition of shares in a public limited company (AG), particularly in cases involving older, internationally structured, or incompletely documented chains of ownership; the various issues regarding proof of ownership and transfer depending on the type of share are outlined above.
| Parameters | Typical Provisions and Negotiation Points |
| Insurance Amount | Up to the amount of the purchase price or the market value of the asset in question. |
| Deductible | Abhängig von Police und Versicherer. Bei eigenständigen Title-Policen können Selbstbehalte sehr niedrig sein oder entfallen; bei Top-up-Strukturen entspricht der Selbstbehalt wirtschaftlich zumeist dem Anknüpfungspunkt oberhalb der W&I-Schicht. |
| De Minimis | Unless otherwise agreed, a separate de minimis threshold applies. Many sets of terms and conditions stipulate that claims below the de minimis threshold are not taken into account; multiple claims arising from the same or a similar underlying circumstance may be aggregated. |
| Policy Term | Linked to the insured person's period of ownership, regardless of the contractual warranty period. |
| Transferability | Negotiable and subject to regular limits. Often, a one-time transfer to a subsequent purchaser or an affiliate within an agreed-upon period after the policy’s effective date is permitted, provided that no claim has been filed and the requirements of the policy terms and conditions are met. |
| Insured Parties | Owner/Buyer; additionally, the financing bank and target companies, if requested |
| Premium Structure | A one-time premium upon enrollment; no ongoing payments. |
| Underwriting Basis | Fokussierte Prüfung der Eigentums-, Anteils- und Übertragungskette auf Basis von Kaufvertrag, Strukturübersicht, Register- und Anteilsunterlagen, historischen Übertragungsdokumenten sowie rechtlichen Due-Diligence- oder Title-Berichten. Bei Immobilien kommen immobilienrechtliche, technische und planungs- oder genehmigungsbezogene Unterlagen hinzu. |
| Benefit Trigger | For standalone title policies: The occurrence of a defined insured event and the resulting financial loss; a breach of warranty under the purchase agreement does not need to be proven. For W&I top-up coverage: The coverage is tied to the underlying W&I or warranty mechanism. |
| Right-back | Legal defense costs may be covered depending on the terms and conditions, but usually only with the insurer’s prior consent. They can be agreed upon in addition to the sum insured and may also reduce the deductible; the specific mechanics depend on the wording of the policy. |
Die Risikoprüfung ist regelmäßig fokussierter als bei einer W&I-Versicherung. Sie betrifft nicht den gesamten operativen Geschäftsbetrieb der Zielgesellschaft, sondern die Eigentums-, Anteils- und Übertragungskette. Die Title Insurance lässt sich deshalb häufig auch kurzfristig und unabhängig vom Verlauf eines W&I-Prozesses prüfen. Praktisch relevant wird das vor allem, wenn ein Eigentums-, Anteils- oder Übertragungsproblem erst spät im Prozess auftaucht, eine Finanzierung an der Absicherung eines Einzelfalls hängt oder die übrige Garantiedeckung bereits verhandelt ist.
Since title insurance only works when an ambiguous ownership, equity, or transfer issue becomes a clearly defined insurable risk, our role begins where a legal assessment must be transformed into a description of an insurable risk: clearly identifying the vulnerabilities in the chain of ownership or equity and specifically reflecting them in the policy terms and conditions. This also involves identifying and eliminating uninsurable issues early on, structuring negotiable individual risks in such a way that they can actually be reflected in the policy, and refraining from resolving risks through insurance when a purchase agreement, registry clarification, or financing requirements are more appropriate solutions.
Title insurance is not a general form of coverage for financial loss, legal risks, or transaction risks. The scope of coverage is determined by the specifically agreed-upon insured events, expressly agreed-upon individual risks, exclusions, and conditions. Typical exclusions include, in particular, risks that were known to the insured but not disclosed; circumstances that were sufficiently apparent in the disclosed documents but were not included as an expressly agreed-upon specific risk; encumbrances created or assumed by the insured; defects that arose after the policy’s effective date, regulatory or governmental approvals that were not obtained, certain insolvency, creditor, or avoidance risks, as well as general exclusions such as war, terrorism, cyber incidents, and communicable diseases.
Public law risks related to construction, use, the environment, planning, or permitting are not automatically included in general title coverage. Depending on the insurer and the policy terms, they may be excluded, but they can also be reviewed and included as a known specific risk, a planning or permitting risk, or an expressly agreed-upon specific risk. Complete and accurate disclosure during the underwriting process is therefore a prerequisite for effective protection. Withheld information and incomplete risk disclosures jeopardize insurance coverage, particularly with regard to the very risk for which the policy was purchased.
Die Title Insurance ersetzt keine allgemeine Due Diligence, keine operative Garantieabsicherung und keine Lösung für Risiken, die einfacher durch Registerbereinigung, Closing Condition, Verkäuferfreistellung oder Kaufpreismechanik gelöst werden können. Bekannte Risiken sind nur dann versicherbar, wenn sie offengelegt, geprüft und ausdrücklich in die Police aufgenommen werden. Nicht geeignet ist die Police für bewusst übernommene Risiken, nachträglich geschaffene Belastungen oder allgemeine Geschäfts-, Steuer-, Umwelt- oder Regulierungsrisiken außerhalb des vereinbarten Deckungsumfangs. Für solche Risiken kommen andere Spezialdeckungen oder kaufvertragliche Lösungen in Betracht.
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute specific legal, tax, or insurance advice. Whether and to what extent insurance coverage is available depends on the specific facts of the case, a legal review, the insurers’ underwriting requirements, and the final terms of the policy.
Do you have any questions?
Call us at +49 89 6223383-0 or email us at: dealinsurance@riskpartners.de.
